Est. 1991

Fired With Passion,
Crafted With Love

For over three decades, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza has been serving the heart of Carle Place, NY with authentic flavors that honor Old World tradition and New York spirit.

33+ Years of Flavor
50K+ Happy Guests
100% Coal Fired
1991 Year Founded
800°F Oven Temperature
40+ Menu Items
4.8 Average Rating
Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza restaurant interior
33+ Years of
Flavor

Born From a Family Love of Authentic Pizza

In 1991, Anthony Russo had a dream: to bring the authentic coal-fired pizza tradition of southern Italy to the streets of Carle Place, New York. Armed with a family recipe passed down through generations and an unwavering commitment to quality, Anthony opened the doors to what would become a Long Island institution.

From day one, the philosophy was simple — use the finest ingredients, cook at the highest heat, and treat every guest like family. Our coal-fired ovens, burning at over 800°F, create a crust unlike anything a conventional oven can produce: crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, with a signature char that tells you it's the real deal.

"The secret isn't in the recipe alone — it's in the fire. Coal gives the pizza a character, a depth of flavor that you simply cannot replicate any other way."

  • Hand-stretched dough made fresh every morning
  • San Marzano tomatoes imported directly from Italy
  • Premium mozzarella sourced from local New York farms
  • Coal-fired ovens reaching over 800°F for that perfect char
  • No shortcuts — every pizza made to order with passion
View Our Menu

Mission, Vision & Values

Everything we do is guided by a set of core principles that have kept us true to our roots for more than three decades.

Our Mission

To craft the most authentic coal-fired pizza experience in New York — using time-honored techniques, premium ingredients, and a genuine passion for bringing people together around great food. Every pizza we make is a tribute to tradition.

Our Vision

To be the definitive destination for coal-fired pizza on Long Island, recognized not just for our exceptional food but for the warm, welcoming community we've built — one meal, one family, one guest at a time.

Our Promise

We promise to never compromise on quality, to always source the finest ingredients, and to ensure every single guest who walks through our doors leaves satisfied, full, and ready to come back — that's the Anthony's guarantee.

What We Stand For

Authenticity

We stay true to the coal-fired tradition — no shortcuts, no compromises, ever.

Quality

Premium, fresh ingredients are non-negotiable. We source the best because you deserve it.

Community

Carle Place is our home. We're proud to nourish the neighborhood that has supported us for decades.

Hospitality

Every guest is treated like a member of the family — warm, welcoming, and always appreciated.

Excellence

We raise the bar with every pie we bake, every dish we plate, every smile we share.

Sustainability

We care about our planet — sourcing responsibly and reducing our environmental footprint.

Innovation

We honor tradition while embracing new ideas — our seasonal specials keep things exciting.

Joy

Food should make you happy. We put joy into every crust, every topping, every bite.

A Legacy Built One Pizza at a Time

Three decades of dedication, growth, and countless delicious memories. Here's how we got here.

1991

The Spark Is Lit

Anthony Russo opens the original location on Old Country Road in Carle Place, NY. Inspired by his grandmother's Neapolitan recipes, the first coal-fired oven is installed and the legend begins.

1997

Community Recognition

Anthony's earns its first "Best Pizza on Long Island" award from the Nassau County Dining Guide. Word spreads far and wide, and weekend waits become a regular occurrence.

2003

Expanding the Menu

Beyond pizza, Anthony's introduces a full lineup of pasta dishes, fresh salads, and Italian-American entrees — all crafted with the same uncompromising quality that built the brand's reputation.

2010

Renovation & Growth

Major renovation of the dining room doubles seating capacity. Two new coal-fired ovens are installed to meet growing demand, while preserving the intimate, family-friendly atmosphere guests love.

2017

Online Ordering Launches

Anthony's embraces the digital era with online ordering for pickup and delivery, making it easier than ever for guests to enjoy coal-fired perfection from the comfort of their own home.

2024

A New Chapter Begins

Anthony's son Marco joins the team as Head Chef, bringing fresh creativity while honoring the traditions that made Anthony's iconic. The next generation of coal-fired excellence has arrived.

Today

Still Fired Up After 33 Years

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza continues to serve thousands of happy guests every week, with the same fire, the same passion, and the same unwavering commitment to authentic flavor that started it all.

Meet Our Team

Our passionate team of culinary experts and hospitality professionals are the heart and soul of Anthony's — dedicated to making every visit exceptional.

Anthony Russo - Founder and CEO

Anthony Russo

Founder & CEO

The visionary behind it all. Anthony's passion for authentic Italian flavors and coal-fired tradition has been the driving force behind every decision since 1991.

Marco Russo - Head Chef

Marco Russo

Head Chef

Anthony's son and culinary prodigy. Trained in Naples, Marco brings fresh innovation to the kitchen while keeping the family traditions alive in every pie he crafts.

Sofia Deluca - Operations Manager

Sofia Deluca

Operations Manager

The organizational force behind smooth daily operations. Sofia ensures that every guest experience is seamless from the moment they walk in to the last bite.

James Moretti - Sous Chef

James Moretti

Sous Chef

With a decade of experience in Italian kitchens, James is the backbone of our back-of-house. His mastery of pasta and appetizers complements our pizza offerings perfectly.

Want to join our family? We're always looking for passionate people.

View Open Positions
Taste the Tradition

Come Experience the Fire for Yourself

Join the thousands of guests who've made Anthony's their favorite pizza destination. Order online for pickup or delivery today.