Authentic Coal Fired Pizza Like No Other
Experience the rich, smoky flavors of our handcrafted pizzas cooked at 900°F in our signature coal-fired oven. Premium ingredients, timeless recipes.
Featured Menu Items
Every pizza, pasta, and salad is crafted with the finest ingredients and cooked to perfection in our iconic coal-fired oven.
Signature Margherita
Our classic coal-fired Margherita with San Marzano tomatoes, fresh buffalo mozzarella, and hand-torn basil leaves. The perfect balance of simplicity and flavor.
Pepperoni Supreme
Loaded with premium pepperoni, Italian sausage, and melted mozzarella on our signature coal-fired crust.
Chicken Arugula
Grilled chicken breast, fresh arugula, shaved parmesan, and lemon-olive oil drizzle on a crispy coal-fired base.
Classic Caesar Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce, house-made Caesar dressing, shaved parmesan, and house-made coal-fired croutons.
Truffle Mushroom
Wild mushrooms, black truffle oil, fresh thyme, ricotta, and smoked mozzarella on a perfectly charred crust.
Passion for Coal Fired Perfection
Founded in Carle Place, New York, Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza has been serving the community with authentic, handcrafted pizzas since 1991. Our coal-fired ovens reach temperatures of 900°F, creating a perfectly charred crust that no conventional oven can replicate.
Every ingredient is sourced with care — from our imported Italian tomatoes to our locally-sourced fresh vegetables. We believe great pizza starts with great ingredients and the right heat.
- Coal-fired ovens at 900°F for the perfect char
- Imported Italian San Marzano tomatoes
- Fresh, locally-sourced produce daily
- Handcrafted dough made fresh every morning
- Family recipes passed down through generations
What Our Guests Say
"Anthony's is hands down the best pizza I've ever had. The crust has that perfect char from the coal oven, and the San Marzano sauce is incredibly flavorful. I drive 30 minutes just to come here at least twice a month. It's become a family tradition!"
"We ordered the Truffle Mushroom pizza and the Chicken Arugula for our office lunch, and everyone was absolutely blown away. The delivery was prompt, everything arrived hot, and the portions are incredibly generous. Anthony's is our go-to for every team celebration!"
"I've tried pizza all over New York and Anthony's stands out for its authenticity. The coal-fired oven makes such a difference — the crust is perfectly crispy on the outside, chewy inside. The staff is always warm and welcoming. Highly recommend the Pepperoni Supreme!"
Visit or Order From Us
Ready to experience the best coal fired pizza in Carle Place? Reach out, visit us, or place your order today.
Find Us
137 Old Country Rd
Carle Place, NY 11514